BMW vs. Lucid Electric Sedans: Performance, Design, and Software Compared
- Authors
- Published on
- Published on
- Name
- By Dushyant
- (@dishs)
In this thrilling comparison, Savagegeese pits the established BMW against the upstart Lucid in a battle of electric sedans. Lucid, a fresh face in the industry, takes a ground-up approach to electric vehicles, prioritizing space and usability over traditional features like V8 engines. On the other hand, BMW opts to adapt an existing model, the 5 Series, dipping its toe into the electric waters. Lucid's design ethos shines through with its spacious interior, akin to a small SUV, and innovative features like doors that open at a striking 90-degree angle, creating an airy and Volvo-like ambiance.
While Lucid impresses with its forward-thinking design, it falls short in software refinement, lacking Android Auto compatibility and facing usability issues like key recognition and subpar audio quality. In contrast, BMW excels in fit and finish, boasting well-developed software that effectively balances physical and touch controls. The interior of the BMW feels more cohesive and roomy, offering a comfortable driving experience that outshines Lucid in terms of overall refinement. When it comes to charging speed, both cars match up due to infrastructure limitations, but Lucid edges ahead in battery efficiency, although real-world range may vary from advertised figures.
The BMW I5, essentially an electric version of the 5 Series, provides customers with various motor options to suit their preferences. The E40 variant, a rear-wheel-drive model with a single motor, packs a punch with 335 horsepower and a 400-volt battery architecture. On the other hand, the Lucid Air Pure RWD, built on a dedicated EV platform, focuses on efficiency and performance, boasting a powerful electric motor that delivers 430 horsepower. With a sporty driving experience in mind, Lucid simulates a limited-slip differential to enhance handling, offering a traditional sports sedan feel with responsive steering and real brake feedback. In a dynamic test at Autobon Country Club, both cars showcase their capabilities, highlighting the unique strengths and characteristics of each electric sedan.
Image copyright Youtube
Image copyright Youtube
Image copyright Youtube
Image copyright Youtube
Watch Lucid Air vs BMW i5 | Battle of Electric RWD Sedans on Youtube
Viewer Reactions for Lucid Air vs BMW i5 | Battle of Electric RWD Sedans
Lucid's driving experience is praised
Some viewers prefer Lucid over BMW for driving dynamics
Positive comments on the channel's thorough reviews and insights
Mixed opinions on the design and interface of both cars
Concerns about the future of BMW and the EV market
Preference for traditional sports cars over EVs for driving experience
Suggestions for Lucid to focus on luxury and release a CUV
Criticisms of BMW's recent models and technology issues
Nostalgia for BMW's past reputation for driving dynamics
Viewer comments on personal preferences for EVs and driving experiences
Related Articles
Unveiling the Maserati mc20 GT2: Track-Ready Performance Excellence
Explore the Maserati mc20 GT2 stradal, a track-focused supercar with a carbon tub and Nuno twin-turbo V6 engine. Discover its performance enhancements, aerodynamics, and driving experience as the team tests it at the escari circuit. Compare it to competitors like the GT3 RS and Lamborghini stto to uncover its unique blend of performance and exclusivity.
Porsche 911 Turbo vs Aston Martin Vantage: Power vs Style Showdown
Porsche 911 Turbo vs Aston Martin Vantage: A showdown of power and style. Discover the technical prowess of the Porsche and the emotional allure of the Aston Martin in this thrilling comparison.
Mini Countryman Review: Pricing, Features, and Performance Analysis
Savagegeese reviews the Mini Countryman, starting at $38,000. The John Cooper Works model, priced over $52,000, offers more power and unique features. Despite its customizable exterior and interior, the car falls short in practicality. Issues include a reflective plexiglass HUD, a laggy infotainment system, and a rough stop-start mechanism. The Mini Countryman JCW, a larger SUV, shares similarities with BMW X1/X2. The JCW variant boasts optimized engine components, wider wheels, and enhanced braking. During the test drive, the team praises the car's power and all-wheel-drive performance but criticizes its narrow power band and abrupt stop-start system. Despite lacking adaptive dampers, the Mini Countryman JCW impresses with its engine and handling. The car's unique character and customization options may appeal to those seeking a distinctive SUV experience.
2025 Volkswagen ID Buzz: Innovative Electric Minivan Review
Discover the 2025 Volkswagen ID Buzz, an innovative all-electric minivan blending nostalgia with futuristic design. Explore its features, pros, cons, and unique driving experience in this in-depth review.