2024 Ford Mustang GT vs Dodge Challenger Shakedown: A Thrilling Muscle Car Showdown

In this riveting comparison test from the MotorTrend Channel, the battle between the 2024 Ford Mustang GT and the Dodge Challenger Shakedown unfolds with all the drama and intensity of a heavyweight bout. Ford, in a bold move, releases an all-new Mustang GT that defies the current trend of electrification, proudly boasting a high-revving V8 engine, a manual transmission, and rear-wheel drive. It's a refreshing nod to the desires of enthusiasts, and with its availability until at least 2032, it promises to keep the fires of passion burning bright.

But alas, the design of the new Mustang GT leaves much to be desired. It's a step backwards, a step sideways, and frankly, a missed opportunity. The grille resembles a rejected Volvo design, and the hastily added big nostrils on the front end only serve to remind us of a Ram pickup truck. The headlights, with their squished appearance and three bulbs, evoke images of the peculiar Citroen SM or the quirky aliens from Toy Story. However, the side of the Mustang GT does have some redeeming qualities, resembling the sleek lines of the Chevy Camaro. The rear, with its Mustang-like tail lights, is somewhat salvaged, but the weird boomerang indent and half-cam back on the trunk lid leave much to be desired. Ford, it seems, has missed the mark with this design.

In stark contrast, the Dodge Challenger Shakedown exudes a timeless appeal that harkens back to the glory days of muscle cars. With its menacing presence, the Shakedown is a sight to behold. The shaker hood, the cool stripes, and the iconic hood pins all contribute to its allure. But it's the air intakes in the headlights and the stunning wide body that truly set it apart. The wheels, oh the wheels, they are a thing of beauty. The Challenger Shakedown is a masterclass in retro design, a testament to the skill of Ralph JS and his team. It's sinister, imposing, and everything a muscle car should be.

When it comes to the driving experience, the Mustang GT falls victim to an identity crisis. It can't quite decide if it wants to be a muscle car or a sports car. The steering is completely numb, leaving the driver disconnected from the road. And while it handles well as a sports car, it falls short as a track car with its long third gear that seems to go on forever. The lack of torque further adds to the confusion. On the other hand, the Challenger Shakedown knows exactly what it is and revels in it. It may not excel in the corners, but when you unleash that big V8 and let the automatic transmission do its thing, it becomes a beast that knows its purpose. Straight-line performance is where the Challenger shines, and there's no denying the sheer joy it brings.

In the end, it's a battle between the heart and the mind. Intellectually, the Ford Mustang GT is the superior car in terms of measurements and performance. It's the better choice for those who prioritize practicality and efficiency. But the heart yearns for the Dodge Challenger Shakedown, with its timeless design and unapologetic focus on pure muscle car enjoyment. It's the car that stirs the soul and brings a smile to your face. So, while the mind may declare the Mustang GT as the winner, the heart can't help but lean towards the Challenger.

Watch Comparison Test: Ford Mustang GT vs Dodge Challenger Scat Pack | MotorTrend on Youtube

Viewer Reactions for Comparison Test: Ford Mustang GT vs Dodge Challenger Scat Pack | MotorTrend

• Challenger vs. Mustang comparison
• Some users accuse Motor Trend of bias towards Dodge
• Discussion about the styling of the Mustang
• Comments about the performance and design of the Challenger
• Mention of other car brands like Volvo and Corvette
• Debate about whether the comparison is fair
• Accusations of bias from both sides
• Disagreement with the reviewer's opinion on Mustang styling
• Some users express their preference for one car over the other
• Discussion about the age of the Challenger's design