Land Rover Defender vs. Ineos Grenadier: A Head-to-Head Comparison

The Land Rover Defender and the Ineos Grenadier are two vehicles that have sparked quite the debate among off-road enthusiasts. The Defender, once known for its rugged body-on-frame construction and solid axle, has now gone the unibody, independent suspension route. It's a move that has divided fans, but Land Rover seems to have found success with over 57,000 units sold in the last few years.

But fear not, for there is a British company called Ineos that has come to the rescue with their Grenadier. This vehicle pays homage to the original Defender, with a body-on-frame construction and solid axle, but with a modern twist. It's like a tribute band that actually sounds good.

Under the hood, the Defender offers a range of engine options, from a 2.0L 4-cylinder turbo to a monstrous 5.0L supercharged V8. But today, we're focusing on the P400, a 3.0L inline-6 turbocharged engine with a mild hybrid setup. On the other hand, the Grenadier is powered by a BMW-supplied B58 3.0L inline-6 engine, which lacks the hybrid technology but still packs a punch.

Now, let's talk about reliability. Some may argue that the Grenadier should have opted for an LS or Toyota-sourced engine, but the BMW engine in the Grenadier has proven itself in numerous BMW models. People have put over 150,000 miles on these engines without any major issues. So, it seems like a solid choice.

In Colorado, Mark is the proud owner of the first Grenadier in the state. He had been eagerly waiting for this vehicle since September 2020 and finally took delivery in November. With just under 1,600 miles on the clock, Mark has already formed some strong impressions. He loves the high seating position and the commanding view it offers. The Grenadier's solid steering and responsive throttle make it a joy to drive on the road.

When it comes to quality, the Grenadier impresses with its solid build and lack of squeaks and rattles. It may not have all the fancy tech features of the Defender, but it makes up for it with its ruggedness and durability. Mark has only encountered a few minor software bugs, which he believes will be fixed with future updates.

In terms of storage, the Defender has the upper hand with its swing open gate and larger trunk space. However, the Grenadier's trunk is still practical and well-built, with durable materials that can handle rough use. Both vehicles offer a unique driving experience, with the Defender's refined interior and the Grenadier's no-nonsense approach.

In conclusion, the Land Rover Defender and the Ineos Grenadier are two vehicles that cater to different tastes. The Defender has embraced modernity with its unibody construction and advanced technology, while the Grenadier stays true to the old-school formula with its body-on-frame design and solid axle. Whichever you choose, both vehicles have their strengths and will surely provide an exciting off-road adventure.

Watch Should Land Rover Defender Be Worried By The Ineos Grenadier - I Drive Both Back To Back! on Youtube

Viewer Reactions for Should Land Rover Defender Be Worried By The Ineos Grenadier - I Drive Both Back To Back!

• The B58 engine is also used in the Toyota Supra, indicating its reliability.
• The speed alert feature is due to new regulations in certain markets.
• The Ineos Grenadier has a customizable cleat system for accessories.
• The aircraft-style overhead switches in the Defender are praised.
• Some users prefer the Grenadier for its off-road capabilities and durability.
• The price of the Grenadier is a deterrent for some.
• The variety of choices for consumers in the 4x4 market is appreciated.
• Some users compare the Grenadier to the G-wagon and the Defender to a luxury AWD.
• Land Rover is criticized for not making working vehicles anymore.
• The Grenadier is seen as more suited for outdoorsmen, while the Defender is seen as a luxury SUV.
• Some users express concerns about the lack of an instrument cluster in the Grenadier.
• The TPMS in the Grenadier may turn off after driving a short distance due to tire expansion.
• The engine choice in the Grenadier is criticized for being underpowered.
• Land Rover's decision to enter the EV market is seen as a strategy to combat depreciation.
• The Land Rover Defender is praised as a great SUV, but not a true replacement for the original Defender.
• The new Land Cruiser is seen as a better option for some users.